1. Home
  2. Travel
  3. Hong Kong / Macau Travel

Review of the Michelin Guide to Hong Kong and Macau

About.com Rating 2.5

By Rory Boland, About.com

The Bottom Line
Overall the Michelin Guide to Hong Kong and Macau is a disappointment. The reviewers seem too focussed on the city’s high end restaurants and haven’t spent enough time hitting the streets to find out where Hong Kongers eat. The restaurants listed in the Michelin Guide to Hong Kong and Macau are worth their stars, but you’ll want a well padded wallet to enjoy a meal at them. See the full list of Hong Kong restaurants with Michelin Stars
Pros
  • The star ratings for the restaurants listed are acccurate
Cons
  • Poor selection of restaurants
  • Focus on high end restaurants
  • Lack of Chinese restaurants
Description
  • Number of Restaurant Reviews - 251
  • Number of Three Star Restaurants - 2
  • Number of Stars at All Restaurants - 28
Guide Review - Review of the Michelin Guide to Hong Kong and Macau

The book manages to eat its way through 251 eateries, including Macau, while awarding three stars to just a pair of restaurants, Lung King Heen inside the Four Seasons Hotel and Robuchon inside the Grand Lisboa in Macau.

Many of the star struck restaurants are parked inside high class hotels, a fact that led to a firestorm of criticism in Hong Kong, quite rightly. Many of Hong Kong’s best Cantonese and Dim Sum restaurants are to be found squirrelled away in back alleys and on the twenty sixth floor of nameless skyscrapers. That’s not to say that the city’s first class hotels don’t serve first class cuisine, they certainly do. They just aren’t the only place for a top quality feed. Quite frankly, The Michelin Guide looks amateurish.

Criticism has also focussed on the fact that in the group of twelve reviewers, only two were Chinese and none were Hong Kong locals. Somewhat ridiculously, the list of restaurants in the book is almost evenly split between European and Chinese cuisine. This is a complete misrepresentation of Hong Kong’s dining scene.

Hong Kong was never going to rival Tokyo’s nine, three-star restaurants, but one listing, plus one in Macau, seems miserly. Lung King Heen is the first Chinese chef to ever earn three stars from Michelin, however this shouldn’t be a source of pride for the guidebook, but of shame, They need to eat out more.

Zagat’s Hong Kong Guide can give you a more accurate view of the city’s dining scene, while Hong Kong Magazine and Time Out Hong Kong have the fingers far better placed on the city’s culinary pulse.

Buy Hong Kong Michelin Guide

Rory Boland is the editor of the hotel section for Zagat Hong Kong

User Reviews Write Review
Explore Hong Kong / Macau Travel
About.com Special Features

Find travel inspiration and get the best tips and reviews for your next getaway. More >

The best times to visit East and Southern Africa. More >

  1. Home
  2. Travel
  3. Hong Kong / Macau Travel
  4. Where to Eat
  5. Should I Buy the Michelin Guide to Hong Kong and Macau - Review of the Michelin Guide to Hong Kong and Macau

©2009 About.com, a part of The New York Times Company.

All rights reserved.